Debate
Questions
Beginner Level: Is live music better than recorded music?
Intermediate Level: Should everyone learn to play a musical instrument?
Advanced Level: Does music have the power to influence people’s emotions and behavior?
SAMPLE ANSWERS:
Beginner Level: Is live music better than recorded music?
For the Affirmative (Live Music is Better):
“Live music is better because it’s more exciting! You can see the musicians playing, and the energy is different. It’s like being part of something special. Also, sometimes the musicians change the songs a little, so it’s a unique experience.”
For the Negative (Recorded Music is Better):
“Recorded music is better because you can listen to it whenever you want. It always sounds perfect, and you don’t have to pay for a ticket. Plus, you can listen to it in your own space, like your room, and you can listen to it while doing other things.”
Intermediate Level: Should everyone learn to play a musical instrument?
For the Affirmative (Everyone Should Learn):
“Learning a musical instrument offers numerous benefits. It enhances cognitive skills, like memory and coordination. It provides a creative outlet for self-expression. Furthermore, it fosters discipline and perseverance. Even if someone doesn’t become a professional, the skills and enjoyment gained are invaluable. Music also is a universal language that can bring people together.”
For the Negative (Not Everyone Should Learn):
“While learning an instrument is beneficial, it’s not practical or desirable for everyone. It requires significant time and financial investment, which some people may not have. Not everyone has a natural aptitude or interest in music. Forcing individuals to learn can lead to frustration and a negative association with music. There are many other valuable skills and hobbies people can pursue that better align with their interests and abilities.”
Advanced Level: Does music have the power to influence people’s emotions and behavior?
For the Affirmative (Music Influences Emotions and Behavior):
“The power of music to influence emotions and behavior is undeniable, supported by scientific research and historical evidence. Music activates neural pathways associated with emotions, releasing neurotransmitters like dopamine and serotonin. Specific musical elements, such as tempo, melody, and harmony, can evoke distinct emotional responses. Furthermore, music is used in various contexts, from advertising to political campaigns, to manipulate moods and sway opinions. Throughout history, music has been a catalyst for social movements, demonstrating its ability to unite people and inspire action. Music therapy is also a growing field, proving musics ability to heal.”
For the Negative (Music’s Influence is Limited or Subjective):
“While music can certainly evoke emotional responses, its influence on behavior is complex and often overstated. Emotional responses to music are highly subjective, varying based on individual experiences, cultural background, and personal preferences. While music can create a mood, whether that mood translates to action is dependent on many outside factors. The idea that music can directly control behavior is a simplification. While music can be used in marketing, people still have free will to make their own choices. Also, there are many other factors that influence human behavior, like social surroundings, and personal life experiences.”